Hoxton Beach drops Hampstead Heath cafe legal challenge
New operators Daisy Green and Cosmin Stuparu to take over five City of London Corporation-run sites.
Hoxton Beach has ceased its legal challenge against the City of London Corporation regarding its eviction from cafés on Hampstead Heath. The company's co-owners, Patrick Matthews and Emma Fernandez, announced on 26 July 2024 that they would not continue with the case, citing insurmountable personal and financial burdens.
The legal proceedings aimed to contest the Corporation's decision in December 2023 to award contracts for five of its cafés to new operators. Hoxton Beach had been running three of these sites: at Parliament Hill Fields Lido, Queen’s Park, and Highgate Wood. The Corporation, which manages the heath and other green spaces, had initiated a procurement process for these cafés.
New Operators Take Over
Under the new arrangements, Daisy Green will operate four of the five premises, including the Parliament Hill Lido and Queen’s Park cafés. Cosmin Stuparu has been awarded the contract for the Highgate Wood café, having previously managed the Golders Hill Park site. The Corporation stated that Daisy Green and Cosmin Stuparu submitted the strongest proposals with the best long-term plans.
The Corporation had initiated possession proceedings in March 2024 to evict Hoxton Beach, alleging the operator remained in unlawful occupation despite being required to leave. While the High Court had previously ruled that the company's request for a judicial review could proceed to a full hearing, the co-owners have now decided to withdraw.
In their statement, Mr Matthews and Ms Fernandez expressed gratitude for the support received over nearly a decade. They noted the unsustainability of operating without the Corporation's support, stating, "We have reached the end of the road."
Community Reaction
The situation had drawn attention from public figures, including actor Benedict Cumberbatch. He had previously voiced concerns about the potential loss of the Lido café in its current form, describing it as "utterly devastating." Mr Cumberbatch expressed hope that the Corporation would prioritise the best interests of the Heath, the Lido, and the local community.
A spokesperson for the City of London Corporation defended its procurement process, asserting it was lawful, open, and the appropriate method to ensure the cafés' future. The Corporation added that it regretted the diversion of charitable resources into legal proceedings and stated its focus is on enhancing the café services, including facility investment, affordable options, and ensuring all staff receive at least the London Living Wage.
The Corporation's procurement process was lawful, open, and the only fair and proper way to secure the future of all five cafés, according to a Corporation spokesperson.
Questions this report answers
01Why has Hoxton Beach dropped its legal case?
Hoxton Beach co-owners Patrick Matthews and Emma Fernandez cited the personal and financial costs of continuing the legal challenge as the reason for dropping their case. They stated the situation had become unsustainable for their operation.
02Who will operate the Hampstead Heath cafés now?
The City of London Corporation has awarded contracts for five cafés to new operators. Daisy Green will run four of the sites, including the Parliament Hill Lido and Queen’s Park cafés, while Cosmin Stuparu will operate the Highgate Wood café.
03What was the City of London Corporation's response to the legal challenge?
The City of London Corporation stated its procurement process was lawful, open, and the correct way to secure the future of the cafés. They expressed regret that charitable resources were used in legal proceedings and confirmed their focus is on improving café services.
Support is available without a police report
Find London services, specialist support and the rights set out in the Victims’ Code. If someone is in immediate danger, call 999.
Find victim supportSend a correction or case update
If a hearing, charge or outcome has changed, send the court, case number and source document so we can update the record.
Contact the desk