Common law protects fundamental rights before Human Rights Act
Judges and academics highlight the historical significance of domestic law in safeguarding liberties.
Incident → evidence → outcomeJudges and academics are increasingly advising that fundamental rights should be sought within the common law before turning to the Human Rights Act 1998. This perspective suggests that domestic legal protections may offer a sufficient basis for safeguarding liberties, potentially negating the need to invoke the HRA in certain cases.
Judicial Emphasis on Domestic Law
Senior judges, including Supreme Court Justices Lord Reed and Lord Briggs, have stressed that the Human Rights Act should not typically be the initial point of reference in cases involving human rights issues. Lord Reed explained that the Act's importance is undeniable, but it does not replace the protection offered by common law or statute. He stated that human rights continue to be safeguarded by domestic law, which is interpreted and developed in accordance with the HRA when appropriate. This means that existing legal frameworks remain the primary source of protection.
Lord Briggs further elaborated on this approach, noting that the common law frequently provides the foundation for legal claims. While the HRA ensures these claims align with Convention standards, it is the common law itself that usually establishes the cause of action. He also pointed out that common law protections can sometimes be more extensive, particularly in situations involving disputes between private individuals.
Historical Context of Common Law Protections
Historically, English common law developed by focusing on remedies for specific wrongs rather than on abstract declarations of rights. As Sir Nicolas Browne-Wilkinson VC observed, legal rights in English law are effectively those that can be enforced through a cause of action. The system was built around providing solutions to defined problems, meaning that the existence of a remedy implied a protected right.
This pragmatic approach meant that rights such as personal liberty and property were protected through available legal actions like trespass or actions related to property. The abolition of the forms of action in the late 19th century did not erase this underlying principle, and its influence continues to shape legal development. Legal scholar A V Dicey highlighted this historical focus, stating that the framers of the constitution concentrated on providing remedies for specific rights or averting definite wrongs, rather than on broad declarations of rights. The Habeas Corpus Acts, for example, were seen as practically more valuable for securing liberty than abstract constitutional articles.
While some rights, like personal liberty and property, were consistently protected, others such as privacy or freedom of assembly were not traditionally viewed as fundamental common law rights. The ongoing academic and judicial interest in common law constitutional rights suggests a continuing exploration of their scope and application.
Questions this report answers
01What is the suggested approach to protecting fundamental rights?
Judges and academics suggest looking to the common law for the protection of fundamental rights before considering the Human Rights Act 1998. This approach prioritises existing domestic legal remedies and interpretations, with senior judges indicating that common law often provides the necessary cause of action for Convention compliance.
02How did English common law historically protect rights?
Historically, English common law focused on providing remedies for specific wrongs rather than explicitly defining rights. A legal right was understood as something protected by an available cause of action. This pragmatic approach meant that rights like personal liberty and property were safeguarded through established legal remedies.
03Do judges believe the Human Rights Act is no longer important?
No, senior judges acknowledge the unquestionable importance of the Human Rights Act 1998. However, they emphasize that it does not supersede the protection of human rights under the common law or statute. Instead, domestic law is interpreted and developed in accordance with the Act when appropriate, with the common law often serving as the primary starting point.
Support is available without a police report
Find London services, specialist support and the rights set out in the Victims’ Code. If someone is in immediate danger, call 999.
Find victim supportSend a correction or case update
If a hearing, charge or outcome has changed, send the court, case number and source document so we can update the record.
Contact the desk