Morgan Rogers penalised for handball in Chelsea's defeat to Leeds
A penalty awarded against Chelsea's Morgan Rogers for raising his arm to the flight of the ball has sparked debate.
Incident → evidence → outcomeA penalty awarded against Chelsea's Morgan Rogers in their 4-1 home defeat by Leeds has drawn scrutiny. The decision, which occurred during the match on Saturday, ultimately contributed to Leeds taking the lead for the first time.
The penalty was given because Rogers raised his arm to intercept the flight of the ball. According to the laws applied by referees, this action, especially when the ball travels a distance, is considered a deliberate act to block the ball. This interpretation overrides other considerations, such as the player's intent to protect their face. Had Rogers kept his arm lower, the ball would have struck his body without consequence.
Rarity of Premier League handball penalties
Despite perceptions, handball penalties are notably rarer in the Premier League compared to other top European leagues. Last season, there were 22 such penalties awarded across 380 Premier League games, the lowest figure among the top five European leagues. In contrast, Spain's La Liga recorded 36, and Italy's Serie A had 38. This season, the Premier League has seen three handball penalties in 106 matches.
Debate over handball interpretations
The decision has highlighted ongoing discussions about handball interpretations. Alan Shearer, a pundit for BBC Match of the Day, expressed his disagreement with the penalty. He stated that officials are not permitted to exercise common sense in these situations, suggesting that Rogers was not deliberately trying to handle the ball but rather attempting to avoid being hit in the face. Shearer noted that while the penalty occurred at a significant point in the game, Chelsea were ultimately outplayed by Leeds.
Chelsea manager Xabi Alonso described the penalty as a harsh decision. He told Sky Sports that he would not have awarded a penalty in that situation. The video assistant referee (VAR), Michael Salisbury, did not intervene, and the on-field decision by referee Michael Oliver was upheld.
The laws of the game consider an arm raised or extended away from the body, or a deliberate act to play the ball, as punishable. While the ball's impact point on Rogers' arm was close to the 'red zone', the area deemed punishable, the primary factor was the upward movement of his arm to meet the ball's trajectory.
Questions this report answers
01Why was Morgan Rogers penalised for handball?
Morgan Rogers was penalised because he raised his arm to the flight of the ball. Referees consider this a deliberate act to block the ball, especially when the shot comes from a distance, and it is punishable under Premier League handball laws.
02Are handball penalties common in the Premier League?
No, handball penalties are relatively rare in the Premier League compared to other top European leagues. Last season, there were 22 handball penalties in 380 Premier League games, which was the lowest tally among the top five European leagues.
03What did Alan Shearer and Xabi Alonso say about the decision?
Pundit Alan Shearer stated that officials are not allowed to use common sense in handball decisions. Chelsea manager Xabi Alonso described the penalty as a harsh decision and said he would not have awarded it.
Support is available without a police report
Find London services, specialist support and the rights set out in the Victims’ Code. If someone is in immediate danger, call 999.
Find victim supportSend a correction or case update
If a hearing, charge or outcome has changed, send the court, case number and source document so we can update the record.
Contact the desk