Trending
Case fileCourtsCity of London

YouTube: Reporting all hate speech would 'inundate' UK authorities

An inquiry heard that the sheer volume of content removed daily makes it impractical to report every instance to law enforcement.

Reporting desk London Crime News Desk||3 min read|London Crime News
YouTube: Reporting all hate speech would 'inundate' UK authoritiesIncident → evidence → outcome
YouTube: Reporting all hate speech would 'inundate' UK authoritiesLondon Crime News

UK authorities would be "inundated" if YouTube were to report every instance of hate speech it removes from its platform, an inquiry has heard. Alexander Rawle, head of UK public policy for YouTube, told the Southport Inquiry that while the company takes down vast amounts of harmful content daily, it is not practical to refer every case to the police.

Mr Rawle was giving evidence to the second phase of the Southport Inquiry, which is examining the management of violence-fixated individuals and the influence of the internet and social media. The inquiry previously found that Axel Rudakubana, who carried out an attack at a Taylor Swift-themed dance workshop, could have been stopped despite being referred to the anti-terror programme Prevent three times. Rudakubana is serving a life sentence for the murders of three children and the attempted murder of others.

Volume of content makes reporting impractical

Nicholas Moss KC, for the inquiry, questioned YouTube's approach to content involving hate speech, incitement to violence, and weapons. He asked if UK law enforcement would feel overwhelmed if YouTube reported such instances. Mr Rawle responded that given the volume of hate speech removed daily in comments and videos, reporting every single one to law enforcement would be impractical.

The barrister highlighted examples of knife-related content on YouTube, including videos depicting the decapitation of pig carcases and human mannequins with fake blood. Mr Rawle suggested such videos might have "legitimate public interest," potentially being news reports or demonstrations of cultural practices like butchery, though he had not reviewed the specific examples himself. He agreed to have YouTube investigate why the content was available as a matter of urgent concern to the inquiry.

Content removal and age-gating

The inquiry heard that footage of a stabbing, watched by Rudakubana minutes before his attack, was still available on X (formerly Twitter). Mr Rawle confirmed that the same video had since been removed from YouTube after being flagged by the inquiry. He explained that such graphic content, if from legitimate news sources depicting events in the public interest, would be age-gated to prevent young users from viewing it, but was considered acceptable for adults.

Mr Rawle acknowledged that children may encounter harmful content on YouTube despite efforts to restrict access. He stated that due to the sheer volume of content, it is inevitable that children will come across harmful material, though he could not confirm if this happens regularly. He also noted that many children are likely "passive consumers" as adults often watch YouTube on televisions in living rooms. Mr Rawle rejected the suggestion that this shifted responsibility onto parents.

Reader briefing

Questions this report answers

Q/A
01What did YouTube's head of UK public policy say about reporting hate speech?

Alexander Rawle told the Southport Inquiry that UK authorities would be "inundated" if YouTube reported every instance of hate speech it removed. He stated that the sheer volume of content makes it impractical to refer every case to law enforcement.

02What is the Southport Inquiry examining?

The inquiry is examining how violence-fixated individuals are managed and the role the internet and social media play in influencing and enabling them. It previously found that Axel Rudakubana, who carried out an attack, could have been stopped.

03What action did YouTube take regarding footage of a stabbing?

YouTube removed footage of a stabbing after it was flagged by the inquiry. This video had been watched by Axel Rudakubana shortly before he carried out his attack. The platform had previously age-gated such content if it was from legitimate news sources.

LC
Source-led case desk

London Crime News Desk

Source-led, editor-supervised

See the reporting protocol →
Help after crime

Support is available without a police report

Find London services, specialist support and the rights set out in the Victims’ Code. If someone is in immediate danger, call 999.

Find victim support
Secure the detail

Send a correction or case update

If a hearing, charge or outcome has changed, send the court, case number and source document so we can update the record.

Contact the desk

Continue the investigation

Who else reported this

Our article above is written from the facts in these reports. Read the originals — every one is linked.

The morning case file

London Crime Briefing

Significant incidents, hearings, outcomes and public-data changes across the capital.

Alexander Rawle: YouTube Hate Speech | London Crime News