Home Secretary Plans Police Impartiality Overhaul
New standards and fast-track leadership development aim to address public perceptions and inconsistent command.
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood will on Wednesday outline significant reforms intended to address what she describes as a "corrosive and growing perception" of two-tier policing across the country. The plans, to be presented to police chiefs, also aim to tackle "inconsistent" leadership within police forces.
A central element of the proposed reforms is the development of a new "impartiality standard." This standard, which will be created by the College of Policing and consulted upon next year, seeks to consolidate guidance on key principles of impartiality. Its aim is to provide police officers with greater confidence in handling cases fairly, irrespective of a person's race, faith, or other characteristics, and to assure the public of equitable treatment.
Addressing Perceptions of Inequality
Ms Mahmood is expected to acknowledge that while the majority of officers police impartially, instances of differential treatment have occurred and have damaged public trust. She will highlight that a recent More in Common poll indicated a third of Britons believe police treat ethnic minority individuals more favourably than white people, a figure that has doubled in the past two years. The Home Secretary also intends to address the low proportion of black officers in police forces, noting that 33 years after the murder of Stephen Lawrence, this figure remains largely unchanged.
However, Ms Mahmood will caution against "misguided attempts at course correction" that could inadvertently lead to differential treatment. She plans to state that the idea of fair policing not meaning treating everyone the same appeared "patently absurd" to the public.
Leadership Development and Fast-Tracking
The reforms will also introduce a fast-track leadership programme designed to develop a new generation of senior officers. This initiative, responding to findings from the Police Leadership Commission, will allow up to 200 recruits to follow a five-to-ten-year path to the rank of superintendent. The programme will be open to serving officers, police staff, and external candidates, with no degree requirement.
This move comes in the wake of July's findings that eight serving or former chief constables were under investigation for misconduct. Ms Mahmood is expected to describe the Police Leadership Commission's conclusions as "candid and eye-opening," stating that police leadership is "inconsistent and at times, it is frankly inadequate," a consequence of past failures to invest in leadership development.
Additionally, Ms Mahmood will advise officers to avoid engaging with "activist groups," urging them to "leave the politics to the politicians." She will define community engagement as attending residents' association meetings to discuss local issues, rather than participating in campaigns driven by external agendas.
Questions this report answers
01What is the new impartiality standard for the police?
The new impartiality standard will be developed by the College of Policing to consolidate guidance on treating all members of the public equally. It aims to give officers more confidence in handling cases fairly, regardless of race or faith, and to build public confidence in impartial policing.
02How will the police leadership be improved?
A fast-track leadership programme will be introduced for up to 200 recruits to reach superintendent rank within five to ten years. This programme is designed to address inconsistent and inadequate leadership identified by the Police Leadership Commission.
03What public perception issues are these reforms addressing?
The reforms aim to tackle the "corrosive and growing perception" of two-tier policing. A recent poll found a third of Britons believe police treat ethnic minority people more favourably than white people, and the proportion of black officers remains low.
Support is available without a police report
Find London services, specialist support and the rights set out in the Victims’ Code. If someone is in immediate danger, call 999.
Find victim supportSend a correction or case update
If a hearing, charge or outcome has changed, send the court, case number and source document so we can update the record.
Contact the desk